Saturday, 14 March 2015

England win the Calcutta Cup, but it was far from a perfect performance

England got the win against Scotland this evening, but many many chances went begging. This could come back to haunt England next week when they, Ireland and Wales will all be playing to win the Six Nations with the winner most likely being the team with the biggest points difference.

Let's start with the man of the match – Ben Youngs. He played much better this week as compared to last week, in particular he finally started to pick up the pace at the breakdown and his partnership with George Ford worked very well today. In my personal opinion, Youngs still has a way to go before I accept his inclusion in the squad. When you look at the speed of Laidlaw today in comparison to Youngs, and the Scotland scrum-half won hands down. Having said that, Ben put his kicking to really good use today and it put England on the front foot time after time (regardless of the fact that we did not take advantage of this most of the time). His partner at fly-half, George Ford, played brilliantly today – he finally managed to take control of the game, much like we see Sexton doing week in week out. His passing was absolutely flawless; he set up some brilliant line breaks for the likes of Burrell, Joseph and Nowell, as well as managing to get himself a try after easily breaking through the flimsy Scotland defence. Kicking-wise, he was pretty much immaculate, only missing one penalty kick and using his kicks from hand to great effect.

In terms of Scotland, for me their best player was Stuart Hogg, which seems to be the case more often than not. He made two incredible try-saving tackles to keep Scotland in the game for most of the match, and was consistently pushing at the England defence. Under the high ball, him and Mike Brown really competed and there was no evidence that they were put-off by the idea that they might be penalised by going up against one another, something we are seeing more often now with soft yellow cards being given in the game. Hogg is one of the best full-backs out there, and sometimes it feels like his talent is being wasted by him playing for Scotland. Mike Brown himself made a welcome return to the Six Nations this evening; he too made two great try-saving tackles and made some great breaks up the field. He even managed to cross the whitewash at one point, but was not awarded the try due to a forward pass by James Haskell. We really missed Brown last week, particularly as Goode was fairly poor, and he came out all guns blazing tonight to help us get the win.

Next, on to who I think was the actual man of the match by a pretty huge margin today – Courtney Lawes. For the past two weekends he has put in exceptional performances for the Saints, and it was no surprise that he was named in the starting squad on Wednesday for today's game. He was a force to be reckoned with all over the field for the whole match, making himself a real nuisance at the breakdown. Add to that the monstrous hits he put in that he has become synonymous for, and he was clearly our most outstanding player today. In last week's match against Ireland one of the main things we were lacking was a real physical presence at the breakdown, and we re-gained that today with the inclusion of Lawes. For Scotland, they had two good players in Cowan and Hamilton who also put in good shifts defensively at the breakdown. They earned their team a few turnovers that allowed them to sink their teeth in the game and actually go in at half-time in the lead. In the second half however, these two were effectively contained by England, particularly Cowan as Hamilton went off after only 47 minutes. This allowed England to get a real foothold in the match, ultimately stopping Scotland from scoring any more points and gifting England the win come the final whistle.

Dougie Fife was another player who had a solid game for Scotland today. He too made some really great breaks, and tried his hardest to keep Scotland on the front foot whenever they had the ball. There is a lot of pace on show when he does get to run with the ball, and he was next to impossible to stop today. In terms of the high ball, he like Hogg competed at the highest level whenever it came his way. In terms of the England wing, Jack Nowell has a mixed game today. He did play so much better than last week, making a lot of breaks and metres, however his passing was way below par. England screwed up multiple chances today to go over the try line, and at least of those was down to a bad pass by Nowell. However, he was not the only one to make any passing or handling errors, as it happened way too often today. The Haskell forward pass in particular was indicative of England's performance – he was standing still and could see exactly where Brown was, yet somehow still managed to pass forward despite the fact that Brown had not overran and could have easily caught the pass had it been thrown correctly.

The person for me who had the worst game for England today was Joe Marler. People always say that he is one of the best and when he is on the field that scrum will work perfectly. But today, he was well below how we know he can play. At the scrum, he gave away multiple penalties for not driving straight and changing the position of his hips. One of these penalties actually went against us on our own ball, and he seemed to be more of a liability than a help today. He just did not want to change his style of play despite constant warnings from the referee. There was no way that he did not know what he was doing, and his actions just seemed really pointless. Vunipola did a better job in the scrum when he came on, but I still feel like England are lacking something in that position. It may be time to bring in someone else to ply their trade in that position and see what can work. There are plenty of great props to choose from!

Just to end on a little high, a quick mention about Burrell and Joseph – their partnership has definitely been a success in this year's tournament. Burrell made some nice breaks, using his power to crash through the defence, and he also made some nice offloads along the way throughout the match. Joseph got back to showing us his electric feet in this match, something we haven't seen much recently, particularly in last week's match when there was no real ball for him to run with. This of course culminated in the first try of the match after five minutes, and again demonstrated just how special a player he is going to go on to be. It would, however, be really nice to see the likes of Slade in the set-up: he would be a great substitute for Burrell, and could even get himself into the starting line-up if he plays well. His inclusion is one thing that all rugby fans seem to be united on – it makes no logical sense that Lancaster has still not named him in his 23, and with him recently being named Premiership Player of the Month for February those shouts for him to the be in the team will just be getting louder.


Overall, it was a good performance from England, but it still was not quite good enough. We need to be way more clinical if we are to beat France next weekend and potentially lift the trophy. Not to mention the fact that we have the World Cup coming, and England have got to clean up their act and become more polished and refined. There is no room for error in the top tier of rugby, and the team still have a lot of developing and growing to do. But to still be in the running to win the Six Nations puts England in a really good place, and they need to grab the bull by the horns next weekend. We are in a really good position playing last because it allows us to know exactly what needs to be done. So now it's onwards and upwards to next weekend, and here's hoping that it will be the men in white lifting the trophy come the end of the day.  

Carry Them Home,
Jess


Twitter: @JessKebbell @RuckMeGently
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Ruck-Me-Gently/743970519052255
Email: ruckmegentlyblog@gmail.com
Website: ruckmegently.blogspot.co.uk

No comments:

Post a Comment

/>